You are here

Gettysburg Battlefield Marathon Organizers Denied Permit

Share

Is it appropriate to stage a marathon at a Civil War battlefield site, or is the hallowed setting the wrong place for runners and cheering? That question has surfaced this week as the organizers of the Gettysburg Battlefield Marathon say the National Park Service has denied their request for a permit to stage this year's race.

"We officially learned Monday the National Park Service will not be approving our permit application as submitted," race organizers Alex Hayes wrote on the marathon's Facebook page. "They have some concerns about the appropriateness of running a marathon on hallowed ground and supporters cheering at places designed for moments of solemn reflection.

"We have mixed feelings about this. We certainly respect the National Park Service’s views in 2018, but are frustrated because the park approached us in 2016 to organize the marathon," they added. "There is new leadership at the park. They have the right to disagree with their predecessors."

Gettysburg National Military Park spokeswoman Katie Lawhon said Thursday that the park did encourage the marathon for 2016 as part of the National Park Service's centennial celebration. While the race returned in 2017, she said park staff decided that the route that was being used was not appropriate for the race.

Concerns voiced by both park staff and Gettysburg visitors, said Ms. Lawhon, concerned "(T)he footprint of the event, so to speak, and the spectators. Water stations and where there were spectators cheering and clapping for hours on end. Those impacts on places, very meaningful places for park visitors” had become an issue.

A central part of the mission of the miliary park, she explained, is to provide visitors with an opportunity to reflect on the soldiers who fell at Gettysburg, and the consequences the battle had on the nation.

"It’s very hard to pair that with what was physically happening here during the marathon," said Ms. Lawhon.

While the marathon in its first two years utilized roads that in some cases literally maked lines of battle and went past "places like Little Round Top and other places where there were major battles," park officials did offer race organizers the use of other park roads that were not so closely aligned with actual battles for this year's race, she said.

“We’re trying to find a way to reduce some of the impacts. If the marathon can still happen or not, it’s up to the organizers," said Ms. Lawhon.

The question of an event's appropriateness in a national park setting is not a new one. Not too many years ago there was a dispute over whether a professional bike race could go through Colorado National Monument. While then-National Park Service Director Jon Jarvis denied that request, there was no opposition when a portion of a professional bike race in Utah went through a sliver of Bryce Canyon National Park, albeit on a state highway.

And for the Park Service centennial, the Tour of Utah bike race was allowed to pedal, not race, through Zion National Park, a move that drew concern from the National Parks Conservation Association.

Comments

I have  belonged to the Gettysburg Foundation for 10 years plus.  I started running in 2014 and was thrilled to run the Gettysburg Battlefield Marathon last November.  My wife met me at several locations during the race.  To say this marathon was disruptive or disrespectful is a joke.  It was Sunday morning in November from 7:00 AM to 1:00.  Granted,  Gettysburg is the Yellowstone of the National Military Parks, so I guess they don't care about keeping interest in the Civil War into the future.   But getting 400 runners and some of their family members to the park during a fall Sunday morning should be applauded, not put to a halt.  This is insane, and bureaucracy at it's worst.  


Let the race begin. There will be no damage to the park. I vote for the marathon.


I had registered for the Gettysburg Marathon for 2017 but had to withdraw due to injury. However, I did go to the race as a spectator. There were very few spectators on the course, even at the finish line and this race has a small field compared to larger races.  I can't imagine that this race would disrupt other visitors and users of the park.  I was raised in the Hanover area and had since moved away.  It was the history of the battlefield that inspired me to want to run the marathon there.  I am very disappointed that the marathon will not be held in 2018. I had planned to register for it again and had been promoting the race to other runners I know in Pittsburgh and other areas.  


The Gettysburg North-South Marathon has been held since 2011 and was granted a permit for 2018, presumably because the footprint of that event was significantly less impact on the tourists, tour buses, etc. in the battlefield.


I feel grateful and privileged to have been able to run the Gettysburg Battlefield Marathon in 2016 and 2017. When I first came to Gettysburg in the summer of 1976, as a medical student working in the Migrant Healthcare Program, I developed an appreciation of the beauty and history of this area. In 1981 I moved my family to Gettysburg and entered into medical practice at the Annie A. Warner Hospital (now Gettysburg Hospital). My family and I for the last 37 years have enjoyed walking and running with friends on the park roads. After moving to Gettysburg I heard from some of the "old timers" about a marathon which had been held in the Gettysburg National Military Park and how much it was valued. However they reported that it was discontinued because the park was felt to be a place of "meditation and not recreation".

I was very excited in 2016 to learn that the Gettysburg Foundation and the Gettysburg YWCA were hosting a marathon in the park. It was noted that the first weekend in November was historically a slow weekend for visitors to the park. It was felt that this event would bring more families to Gettysburg and also be least likely to impact other activities around town. As part of the registration were included tickets to the Gettysburg National Military Park Visitor Center with access to the Cyclorama painting and "New Birth of Freedom" film. It was great to see the enthusiasm of families at registration at the Park Visitor Center looking forward to their first weekend in Gettysburg.

The race in 2016 was on a perfect fall day. The turnout was good for a first time event. In 2017 it rained all night and into the morning of the race but despite that there was an enthusiastic gathering for the start of the full and half marathons. Because of the weather there were few spectators along the race route. There was an energized group of family, volunteers and civil war reenactors at the finish. They did make a lot of noise but this was in the remote parking lot behind the Park Visitors Center. This was an inspiring and joyful event for everyone involved. It was a tribute to those volunteers who put so much time and effort into making it a memorable event for participants and their families.

As a longtime member of the Marine Corps Marathon club I am always inspired starting the Marine Corps Marathon at the Arlington National Cemetery and finishing at the Marine Corps War Memorial. I find that an event that takes me past the memorials honoring our past service men and women is humbling and inspiring.

I do agree that recreational activities should not be held in such locations as the Gettysburg National Cemetery. However I feel there can be a balance between "meditation and recreation". Families come to Gettysburg for both and learn from both. I hope that there will be some way to continue the good work that was seen in 2016 and 2017.


A well managed and controlled event --Special Use Permits, cost recovery - and an ongoing dialog with the organizers are essential. When a park hosts such an event it is vital for the education and outreach about the park to take place. I could see Battlefields having one of these events, and doing the 'see if your ancestors fought here' for the racers and their families. (doesn't have to be park staff)

Also, how young many of the soldiers were...I remember one tour where the guide explained that the soldiers were standing close enough to HEAR the order given by their opponent to KILL them. A revolutionary war battlefield has had visitors not believe that people DIED there (on the Battlefield). Getting different groups of people out and engaged in the historic sites in a manner they enjoy (crazy runners - have at it) and able to learn as they go are terrific ambassadors for keeping the site there.

The key is, well run, rules and expectations discussed and ruthlessly enforced by race organizers and NPS staff when appropriate. 


I'm totally bummed that there will be no battlefield marathon/half this year. I was planning to make a trip from Georgia to run it--to beat the race that "almost beat me."

In 2013, my husband ran the Blue/Gray half, and I almost missed him at the finish line, because I was so out of shape. So this was going to be the almost 5th anniversary, since I started my health journey, and began running. I guess I'll just run Chickamauga's--which ironically is in its 39th year.


Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.