You are here

Welcome Gun Owners!

Share

Published Date

November 20, 2006

    Boy, the gun clubs passed the word this weekend about my post on outgoing Senator George Allen's last-gasp effort to legalize the carrying of concealed weapons in national parks.
    The flurry of comments against my post and in favor of Allen's bid was impressive. Not quite so impressive were the few comments that questioned my sexuality and maturity because I don't take glee in toting a 10 mm Glock or my ability to think critically.
    Under most of the counterarguments offered, the general thinking seems to be that to protect ourselves we all should be carrying our own gleaming, semi-automatic, or perhaps even automatic, pieces to ensure safety in society. Frankly, folks, I don't see how that's going to accomplish much beyond an increase in the number of shoot-outs.
    And yes, I'm well familiar with the old cliche that if you outlaw guns, only outlaws will own guns. Just the same, is mass arming how you measure 21st century progress?
    There's no doubt that there are some parts of the park system that are increasingly dangerous, be it from the drug operations in Sequoia or the illegal immigration coming through Organ Pipe. And that's why we have growing numbers of law enforcement rangers battling those problems. By and large, though, I don't see the parks as having become so dangerous that we need to revert to a freelance form of posse comitatus.
    And I certainly can't see the law enforcement arm of the National Park Service jumping on this proposal.
     Perhaps if those who believe they should be able to carry their weapons wherever they please focused that same fervor on lobbying Congress to properly fund the National Park Service the parks would become a safer place than they already are.
    That said, it's great to see so many comments on a topic that certainly needs some debate. And I encourage more discourse. Just please try to erase your juvenile insults before you push the "post" button.

Comments

Hmm, I suppose my position on this makes me one of those "new Democrats" that have a chance of winning in the South...but not quite. I've done extensive hiking in Arizona and the Blue Ridge Mtns, and I frequently bring my revolver -- not because I'm worried about criminals, though. I'm thinking more about rattlesnakes and mountain lions, and I load it mostly with snakeshot and think largely about its noise-making capacity. It's also not a concealable weapon, and I was used to seeing hikers walk around in AZ with a six-shooter on their hip. It was just as natural a hiking tool as a Leatherman and a good Zippo. I'd prefer to keep that tool on my hiking list no matter where I hike. At first my more liberal side started thinking, "Revolver on the hip, fine, but isn't a concealed-carry extension a bit much for hiking?" But I think there's a morsel of truth in what some of your rabid NRA commenters pointed out: it's that shadow of uncertainty about what a potential victim is capable of that might dissuade a certain class of robber (naturally it won't dissuade all criminals). Where I think the NRA types are wrong is in the blanket assumption that "criminals are law-breakers anyway so they're going to carry a gun no matter what the law says." That's not always true: again, there's a certain class of petty criminal that wants your wallet, but not so much to risk the penalty-enhancement brought about by firearm possession. Double trouble for the petty crook if we actually had more extensive regulations and enforcement concerning *licensed* versus *unlicensed* firearms. The problem is, the extreme 2nd Amendment types are so dead-set against letting us more moderate types regulate the possession and registration of firearms that it's very hard for the unarmed hikers and the gun-toting GI Joes to meet in the middle for a sensible compromise.

I am having trouble understanding why anyone needs to cary a firearm in the Parks. Most of you agree that you're pretty unlikely to be robbed at gun/knife point. And the idea that we need to protect ourselves from the snakes and mountain lions disturbs me. How many people are injured or killed by these ruthless animals? Are we not the ones intruding into their homes and then defending our behavior with violence. If that is you defense then you will never be welcome in my house

The folks who seem to think national parks are some sacred ground where the Second Amendment alone should be restricted need to rethink. Let's get something straight: concealed carry permit holders simply do not commit crimes. You won't be raped, robbed or assaulted by a concealed carry person. You won't even know they're out there unless you attack one - just as you don't know about all of the criminals out there. Not one of the anti-gun posters has complained about the CRIMINALS in the parks and how they're concerned about how criminals will assault them as they do many times. They don't complain about their fear of knowing criminals will break laws to get what they want. No, they're complaining about lawful exercise of Constitutional rights that are now abridged by silly regulatory and geographic prohibition. I'll forego discussion of the stereotypical anti-gun terminology.

Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Your support helps the National Parks Traveler increase awareness of the wonders and issues confronting national parks and protected areas.

Support Our Mission

INN Member

The easiest way to explore RV-friendly National Park campgrounds.

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

Here’s the definitive guide to National Park System campgrounds where RVers can park their rigs.

Our app is packed with RVing- specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 national parks.

You’ll also find stories about RVing in the parks, tips helpful if you’ve just recently become an RVer, and useful planning suggestions.

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

FREE for iPhones and Android phones.