You are here

Split 9th Circuit Court Rejects Trump Administration's Wall Funding Arguments

Share

Published Date

July 8, 2019

9th U.S. Circuit Court judges, in a split decision, have blocked the Trump administration's effort to use Defense Department funding to build a border wall through Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument/Patrick Cone file

A split 9th U.S. Circuit Court Of Appeals has denied the Trump administration's efforts to tap military funding for a wall along the country's southern border, with the majority saying the administration's efforts were an unconstitutional appropriation of Congressional authority.

The ruling, for now, blocks a 30-foot wall with "all-night floodlighting" from being installed along the southern border of Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument in Arizona with Mexico.

The case revolved around U.S. Customs and Border Protection plans to build a tall barrier wall along the monument's 63-mile-long boundary with Mexico. Late last month a federal judge in California blocked the plan to build a wall with concrete-filled steel bollards that are approximately 6 inches in diameter. U.S. District Judge Haywood S. Gilliam, Jr., acting on a lawsuit brought by the Sierra Club and the Southern Border Communities Coalition, held that it was illegal for the Trump administration to use $2.5 billion in funds appropriated to the military to pay for the border wall.

The administration asked the 9th Circuit to stay that ruling until it could be further litigated, but the appellate court's majority rejected that request.

"There is a strong likelihood that Plaintiffs will prevail in this litigation, and Defendants have a correspondingly low likelihood of success on appeal," wrote the majority opinion signed by Judges Richard Clifton and Michelle Friedland. "As for the public interest, we conclude that it is best served by respecting the Constitution’s assignment of the power of the purse to Congress, and by deferring to Congress’s understanding of the public interest as reflected in its repeated denial of more funding for border barrier construction."

But in his dissent, Judge N.R. Smith said the lower court hadn't fully ruled on the Constitutional question of the Executive Branch's authority, only that it ruled on whether the administration had violated a statute, and so his two colleagues had wrongly turned the case into a Constitutional matter. Further, Judge Smith maintained that since Congress had given the Defense Department a "lump sum" appropriation, it gave the department discretion in deciding how those funds are spent.

"The majority’s approach would turn our current system of administrative review on its head, directing courts in this circuit to deem unconstitutional any reviewable executive actions that exceed a statutory grant of authority," wrote the judge. "Such an approach directly contradicts the Supreme Court’s declaration that '[o]ur cases do not support the proposition that every action by the President, or by another executive official, in excess of his statutory authority is ipso facto in violation of the Constitution.'"

Administration attorneys had argued before the 9th Circuit that if the money transfer wasn't enabled by the end of the current fiscal year, September 30, it would no longer be available.

Sierra Club staff were greatly concerned how the proposed wall and its construction would impact Organ Pipe Cactus.

"The entire southern boundary of Organ Pipe would be walled off by what has been described as a 30-foot wall with all-night floodlighting," Dan Mills, of the Sierra Club's Grand Canyon Chapter Borderlands Program, told the Traveler last week. "The contractor is already there on the ground, doing surveys and planning work. They’re talking about drilling new wells to do onsite concrete mixing for the foundation and for filling the steel posts. So it would be an enormous change."

Support National Parks Traveler

National Parks Traveler is a small, editorially independent 501(c)(3) nonprofit media organization. The Traveler is not part of the federal government nor a corporate subsidiary. Your support helps ensure the Traveler's news and feature coverage of national parks and protected areas endures. 

EIN: 26-2378789

Support Essential Coverage of Essential Places

A copy of National Parks Traveler's financial statements may be obtained by sending a stamped, self-addressed envelope to: National Parks Traveler, P.O. Box 980452, Park City, Utah 84098. National Parks Traveler was formed in the state of Utah for the purpose of informing and educating about national parks and protected areas.

Residents of the following states may obtain a copy of our financial and additional information as stated below:

  • Florida: A COPY OF THE OFFICIAL REGISTRATION AND FINANCIAL INFORMATION FOR NATIONAL PARKS TRAVELER, (REGISTRATION NO. CH 51659), MAY BE OBTAINED FROM THE DIVISION OF CONSUMER SERVICES BY CALLING 800-435-7352 OR VISITING THEIR WEBSITE. REGISTRATION DOES NOT IMPLY ENDORSEMENT, APPROVAL, OR RECOMMENDATION BY THE STATE.
  • Georgia: A full and fair description of the programs and financial statement summary of National Parks Traveler is available upon request at the office and phone number indicated above.
  • Maryland: Documents and information submitted under the Maryland Solicitations Act are also available, for the cost of postage and copies, from the Secretary of State, State House, Annapolis, MD 21401 (410-974-5534).
  • North Carolina: Financial information about this organization and a copy of its license are available from the State Solicitation Licensing Branch at 888-830-4989 or 919-807-2214. The license is not an endorsement by the State.
  • Pennsylvania: The official registration and financial information of National Parks Traveler may be obtained from the Pennsylvania Department of State by calling 800-732-0999. Registration does not imply endorsement.
  • Virginia: Financial statements are available from the Virginia Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, 102 Governor Street, Richmond, Virginia 23219.
  • Washington: National Parks Traveler is registered with Washington State’s Charities Program as required by law and additional information is available by calling 800-332-4483 or visiting www.sos.wa.gov/charities, or on file at Charities Division, Office of the Secretary of State, State of Washington, Olympia, WA 98504.

Comments

If the wall proceeds as planned, PLEASE take into consideration dark sky lighting options!  Organpipe has a great Star gazing program that would be negatively impacted by constant outward night lighting.  The glow from RockyPoint Mexico is bad enough, let's not add more stupid lights to the mix!


In the words of Gomer Pyle - "suprise, suprise, suprise" - not.

 

 


Well, ecbuck, considering that 2 of the judges on the 3-judge panel that heard this case were Republican (George W. Bush) appointees, this is indeed a hopeful surprise.  One of them defected and joined the Democratic (Obama) appointee to uphold the permanent injunction (on funding the Organ Pipe wall, and the wall in other sectors too, by "emergency"-redirected DoD funds).  If this does go to the Supreme Court, and there likewise only one Republican appointee defects, this injunction will hold.  That is, if the Supreme Court even agrees to hear the case; if two Republican appointees defect, it may not even do that.


Well dscott - as Justice Roberts has shown, who appointed them and their registered party at the time doesn't determine whether they will stick to Constitutional principles.  The 9th is notoriously left leaning and as I predicted bent that way again.


Your support helps the National Parks Traveler increase awareness of the wonders and issues confronting national parks and protected areas.

Support Our Mission

INN Member

The easiest way to explore RV-friendly National Park campgrounds.

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

Here’s the definitive guide to National Park System campgrounds where RVers can park their rigs.

Our app is packed with RVing- specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 national parks.

You’ll also find stories about RVing in the parks, tips helpful if you’ve just recently become an RVer, and useful planning suggestions.

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

FREE for iPhones and Android phones.