You are here

Acting National Park Service Director Says He's Cleared Of Harassment Charge

Share

Published Date

June 1, 2018
Daniel Smith, National Park Service

Daniel Smith apologized Friday to all Park Service employees for crude behavior he exhibited in the Interior Department/NPS

While the acting director of the National Park Service says grabbing his crotch in an Interior Department hallway was inappropriate, he told the agency's employees Friday that he's been cleared of behavior that constituted harassment.

In a short email to all Park Service employees, P. Daniel Smith said Interior's Office of Inspector General had completed its investigation into an anonymous allegation leveled in March that he grabbed his genitilia in a crude manner while walking down the hallway with Bert Frost, the regional director of the Park Service's Alaska office. Mr. Smith, a deputy director of the Park Service acting with the authority of the director, said he was recounting a story from time he spent in Alaska.

The allegation presented to Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke claimed that Mr. Smith “grabbed his crotch and his penis and acted out as though he was urinating on the wall."

"I want to start by apologizing to any colleague who witnessed this," Mr. Smith wrote in his email. "I recognize that the story was inappropriate for the workplace, even though it does not rise to the level of harassment. I am very sorry for my mistake in telling this story and any discomfort it clearly caused.

"I also want to apologize to each of you. As a leader, I must hold myself to the highest standard of behavior in the workplace. I take my responsibility to create and maintain a respectful, collegial work environment very seriously. Moving forward, I promise to do better."

Sexual harassment has been an issue the Park Service has been grappling with in recent years. According to a survey of workforce behavior launched in 2016, 38.7 percent of the Park Service respondents complained about some form of harassment. Slightly more than 19 percent reported gender harassment, and 10.4 percent reported sexual harassment.

In the wake of that survey, Secretary Zinke promised immediate and lasting reform, saying "there’s an expectation that not only can (the Park Service) be the greatest stewards of our lands, but also they should be the greatest stewards of our values."

"In the past, zero tolerance has been an empty phrase. Instead of taking real action against harassment, the National Park, some leadership, has fallen back and taken no action," he said during an October 2017 media call. "Clearly, there has been sexual harassment, intimidation, retaliation within the Service, and that is not in keeping of the traditions of the fine Service itself.

“I can tell you, from the president and myself, that’s over. We’re going to root out this virus, and it begins with putting a new culture forward, a culture that embraces diversity of thought, embraces teamwork, a culture that embraces the best of the Park Service values and understanding how important it is of being the stewards of our greatest treasures."

While the OIG investigation into Mr. Smith's actions has been completed, it will not be released to the public until 30 days have passed, the OIG staff said Friday.

"I hope that my mistake and this apology are a lesson for leaders and employees at every level of the National Park Service," Mr. Smith summed up. "Workplace culture is our shared responsibility. We must conduct ourselves in a manner that reflects the great pride we all have for the extraordinary parks and programs we represent."

Traveler reached out to Interior Department spokeswoman Heather Swift on Friday afternoon to ask if Secretary Zinke would seek any disciplinary action, and was awaiting a response.

Mr. Smith was investigated more than a decade ago by the OIG staff after being implicated for improperly paving the way for the owner of the Washington Redskins to cut down trees on a 2-acre scenic easement along the Chesapeake & Ohio Canal National Historical Park.

Mr. Smith, at the time special assistant to then-NPS Director Fran Mainella, was found by the Inspector General to have "inappropriately used his position to apply pressure and circumvent NPS procedures" to permit Redskins owner Dan Snyder to have trees up to 6 inches wide at breast height on the easement cut down to improve the Potomac River view from his mansion.

According to the investigation by then-Inspector General Earl Devaney's staff, the Park Service failed to conduct the requisite environmental assessment as required by the NPS Director's Handbook before issuing the special user permit to Mr. Snyder.

Mr. Smith had become involved in the matter in 2002, according to the OIG report, and in 2004 called Chesapeake and Ohio Canal staff to say that, "Snyder was not happy with the pace of negotiations with NPS concerning the scenic easement."

"The C&O NHP Lands Coordinator admitted that after his conversation with Smith, he felt pressure to secure an agreement with Snyder," the report (attached below) added. "He related that he met with Smith at least twice after the call, once at Snyder's residence in June 2004 and another time on the C&O Canal towpath below Snyder's residence."

After the tree-cutting episode, Mr. Smith was appointed superintendent of Colonial National Historical Park in Virginia. He retired in 2014 after 10 years as superintendent of Colonial National Historical Park in Virginia, but returned to the Park Service in January. While the Trump administration has not named a permanent Park Service director, Mr. Smith has been acting as such.

Comments

Not exactly, Kurt.  The letter did not mention the alleged crotch-grabbing at all: it did not deny it or apologize for it, just omitted it.  The letter apologized for the "story ... inappropriate for the workplace", inappropriate behavior in a public hallway, a "hallway conversation".

 


I can see how you might read it that way, tomp2, but readers unfamiliar with the story need to know what the allegation was and what Mr. Smith was apologizing for. Obviously he knows that his actions, not what he was telling Mr. Frost, were at the crux of the matter.


Time to move on.  He apologized. The dude has a target on his back. No one should be subjected to an article in the Washington Post before an investigation is completed.

I wasn't there I don't know the specifics but walking the halls of any DOi offices these days is not enjoyable.  Everyone needs to watch their backs!!

Just a comment.  Can we put the OIG report from the C and O Canal to rest. It is old news and everyone has moved on. Give the guy a break. 

 

 


It appears to me that this man has only hiked from one high roller office to the next in and around Capitol Hill. Hope his canteen wasn't full of scotch.

 


MF--

I wasn't there, either.  I agree: let's move on, although I wish the apology letter actually mentioned the alleged crotch & penis grabbing that was the reason for the complaint.  Old guard guys tell such stories to each other, sorta an odd but widespread ritual.  [Wildlife biologists tell worse/funnier (to them anyway) stories usually involving other species' behaviors, but they tend to know when & where it is and is not ok to do so.]  I also wish the "acting with delegated authority" de facto NPS director was smart and aware enough to know not to tell such stories in Eye St. or Main Interior, but you go to work each day with the leaders you have, not the leaders you wish you had.

Maybe they can include this incident in the next bout of mandatory DOIlearn anti-harassment training?  Or else make Mr. Smith actually take that training?


What a colossal waste of time and resources. Sounds more like someone with an axe to grind or looking for an excuse to be offended over nothing.


MF, as a volunteer at C&O, I'd say that the legacy of actions by Dan Smith and other park managers (who are still there from the days of the OIG report) still linger. It would be nice to move on but some of the same issues remain.


The Trump Administration should never have appointed Daniel Smith as Acting NPS Director.  He should have remained in retirement. The C&O Canal incident is not just old news, and the OIG Report of Smith's misconduct in granting an illegal favor to a billionaire should have been in itself disqualifying.  Rob Danno, then the Chief Ranger at C&O took the ethical route and had his career, up to then exemplary, ripped from him.  The crude behavior which Smith has been accused of, and his half-apology, reinforce the perception from the OIG Report of a manager unfit to lead.  The Trump Administration has not appointed a permanent director for any of the principal Interior Agencies (NPS, BLM, USFWS).  All have acting directors 18 months into the current Administration.  This is a disgrace, and a disservice to the public and the DOI's employees.


Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Your support helps the National Parks Traveler increase awareness of the wonders and issues confronting national parks and protected areas.

Support Our Mission

INN Member

The easiest way to explore RV-friendly National Park campgrounds.

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

Here’s the definitive guide to National Park System campgrounds where RVers can park their rigs.

Our app is packed with RVing- specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 national parks.

You’ll also find stories about RVing in the parks, tips helpful if you’ve just recently become an RVer, and useful planning suggestions.

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

FREE for iPhones and Android phones.