You are here

Traveler's View: Interior Department Makes Rules Up On The Fly

Share

Published Date

January 7, 2019

These are troubling days or the National Park System and National Park Service/NPS file

With the Interior Department led by a recent oil industry lobbyist and the National Park Service by a past political appointee who overlooked environmental rules to please a billionaire, we're embarking on a new paradigm for managing the National Park System, one that includes changing the rules on the fly.

Either truly concerned about the public's welfare, bothered by congressional delegations that want national parks fully staffed during the ongoing partial government shutdown, or refusing to question their original decision to keep parks open, top Interior and NPS officials in Washington, D.C., huddled Sunday and decided it would be better to use monies dedicated to improve visitor services on basic custodial services rather than closing the parks until President Trump and Congress can negotiate a way through their impasse over a wall on the country's border with Mexico. They made no mention of recently ousted Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke's suggestion that folks heading to the parks take a trash bag with them.

As the partial shutdown moved into its third week, many parks were overflowing with trash and human waste. The lucky ones, those with financially sound friends organizations and/or states that saw an investment in cleaning restrooms was better than losing tourism dollars, have for the most part been able to weather the drama.

Officials at Sequoia and Kings Canyon national parks couldn't, and closed both parks entirely last week. Joshua Tree, Big Bend, and Death Valley closed some campgrounds. Arches, Canyonlands, Rocky Mountain, Theodore Roosevelt, Badlands, and Wind Cave closed roads. Muir Woods National Monument was scheduled to close today, January 7.

Social media went full throttle in the blame game, with etiquette tossed in the overflowing trash bins.

A bit more than four years ago the government went through a full shutdown, for 16 days. Under President Obama, the entire National Park System was closed down. The move brought more than a little criticism, as planned weddings and river trips alike were affected, and not in a good way. An editor for an automobile magazine thought it would be the perfect time to take his dirt bike through Great Smoky Mountains National Park, including through a stream. Vandals in California hit Santa Monica Mountains National Recreation Area, where they cut open locks to gates barring entry to the recreation area. Though seemingly innocuous, Santa Monica Mountains officials were concerned that visitors unaware of the closure could find themselves deep in canyons where they could be trapped by wildfires. October, if you didn't know, is peak wildfire season.

Afterwards, the political blame game ensued (as it still does today if you bring up that shutdown: "Obama closed the parks," or "Ted Cruz did!"). Then-National Park Service Director Jon Jarvis was summoned to an hours-long joint hearing of the House Oversight and Natural Resources committees, where Republican members took him to the woodshed. Talking to Jarvis the other day, the former Park Service director recalled that hearing.

"I got grilled on the hill for five hours over it, and being accused that closing them was a political act," he told me. "And I vehemently disagreed with that, that it was a stewardship act, that we felt that without the employees there to manage and provide stewardship, that the parks would be vulnerable to impact. I think we’re actually seeing that play out now.”

We are seeing it, both in how the parks have filled with trash and been hamstrung in managing visitors. Not everywhere, of course. Zion National Park visitors reportedly have been respectful and tidy. Some at Big Bend, Yosemite, Joshua Tree and elsewhere, not so much.

And, too, we're seeing it in Washington with how politicians are bending, and possibly breaking, the rules for how Park Service revenues are to be spent. Along with spending fee revenues on basic custodial services, Park Service regulations have prohibited the use of fees to pay for salaries of permanent personnel.

This move also raises the question of whether Congress will figure the Park Service can pay for more things with fee revenues than general appropriations. And it figures to have an impact on deferred maintenance. Just a month ago more than a few members (on both sides of the aisle) in Congress were working hard to pass legislation to address a good portion of the maintenance backlog. Now they're not only back at square one with that effort, but it could get a bit more complicated with this fee swap decision.

If anyone is wondering, this is not the way to run the world's preeminent park system.

Comments

You nailed it Kurt.

These short sighted decisions to win the approval of the Administration will cripple the NPS.   Closing the parks was the exact right call by these Supts but they are clearly being undercut.  It is ironic that a Department who wants to reorganize to bring decisions closer to the field is demonstrating exactly what will happen. All important decisions for the parks in a reorganized DOI will be made by the 6th Floor at Main Interior and not in the parks or regions.

 Welcome to the  future - elections have consequences.

 BTW. has Mitch McConnel gone missing at Mammouth Cave?


" BTW. has Mitch McConnel gone missing at Mammouth Cave?"

If he has, let's not report it to the rescue teams . . . 


Well spoken, Kurt. 


Leave no trace.  A lost lesson because of liberal nanny state policies.     The government will take care of you so do what u want with no consequences.  Let the public figure out that they can not do as they please.  Abit Vigilanty enforcement will go a long way as well.


OK, Mr Vigilante Enforcement. We heard enough about your sort of "tyranny fear" when y'all piddled on the floor of our wildlife refuge.

Had you paid attention in school you may have learned that dating way back to the caveman, the reason that hunters came together into shared caves was so that the group can help the weaker or young or elderly in the group survive. After that, opinions abound. Where one person might say "liberal nanny state" another person might say "why doesn't anyone do something to help these poor people?" 


Freeusfromtyranny:

Leave no trace.  A lost lesson because of liberal nanny state policies.     The government will take care of you so do what u want with no consequences.  Let the public figure out that they can not do as they please.  Abit Vigilanty enforcement will go a long way as well

Those are trail ethics.  One of the major tenets is to "dispose of waste properly".  I don't condone dumping waste wherever since the containers are full, but this was an understandable outcome.


The parks should have been closed to protect the environment, animals, and visitors.  This has nothing to do with "liberal nanny state" policies.  The current president is destroying our national parks just as he is doing to all American institutions. Hopefully, this shutdown will end soon and qualified professional Rangers will be back on the job of protecting our parks.


CC - Could you please identify what National Park has been destroyed and how.

 


Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Your support helps the National Parks Traveler increase awareness of the wonders and issues confronting national parks and protected areas.

Support Our Mission

INN Member

The easiest way to explore RV-friendly National Park campgrounds.

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

Here’s the definitive guide to National Park System campgrounds where RVers can park their rigs.

Our app is packed with RVing- specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 national parks.

You’ll also find stories about RVing in the parks, tips helpful if you’ve just recently become an RVer, and useful planning suggestions.

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

FREE for iPhones and Android phones.